Format: 432 pages, Hardcover
Release Date: August 5, 2025
Publisher: Little, Brown Books for Young Readers
Source: Publisher
Genre: Historical, Mystery, Suspense
In Oxford’s All Souls College, Isaac Holland is pitted against the brightest of Britain’s young elite for a seat amongst the prestigious school’s faculty. The Victorian Era is reaching its apex, and the ancient hallways and corridors of Oxford teem with ghosts and secret societies. Isaac finds the competition increasingly cutthroat and diabolical, but there are more pressing concerns. One, that someone—or something—is murdering Isaac’s fellow students, one by one, in ways more gruesome than the next. And two, that Isaac’s real name is actually Irene Adler. A retelling of Sherlock Holmes from the perspective of the one woman to ever outwit him, A Beautiful and Terrible Murder follows Irene Adler and Sherlock Holmes as they are forced to work together to hunt down a murderer at Oxford who is killing their classmates.
A Beautiful and Terrible Murder is the first installment in author Clair Andrews Irene Adler series. A retelling of Sherlock Holmes from the perspective of the one woman to ever outwit him, A Beautiful and Terrible Murder follows Irene Adler and Sherlock Holmes as they are forced to work together to hunt down a murderer at Oxford who is killing their classmates. In 1872, Oxford, Irene Adler lives a daring double life. As "Isaac Holland," she disguises herself as a young man to attend the elite, all-male All Souls cohort—a competitive preparatory program for Oxford's brightest minds.
She also attends classes openly as herself at the women's college, Lady Margaret Hall. This setup lets her pursue the education denied to women in Victorian England. When fellow All Souls students begin turning up dead, Irene (as Isaac) gets pulled into the investigation. Her roommate, the brilliant but enigmatic Sherlock Holmes, becomes an unlikely partner. Tensions rise as someone frames Isaac for the murders, and Irene's own father—Dean Moriarty—threatens her place at the school.
Her half-brother, the notorious James Moriarty, adds further complications. The story blends murder mystery, academic intrigue, and subtle romance against the gothic backdrop of Victorian Oxford's spires, libraries, and shadowy halls. Fans of Stalking Jack the Ripper or Enola Holmes-style adventures will find familiar vibes here. Andrews gives Irene a compelling, proactive role that the original Conan Doyle canon only hints at. She's sharp, resourceful, and fiercely determined— a strong female lead who carries the narrative in first-person perspective.
Her disguise adds constant tension and highlights themes of gender, ambition, and societal constraints. The book moves quickly with twists, red herrings, and escalating danger. Many readers note they didn't guess the killer until late, and the investigation keeps pages turning. The dynamic between Irene and Sherlock delivers witty banter and intellectual sparring. Supporting characters (including a young Watson) add depth. Holmes fans will enjoy this younger, developing version of the detective.
Certain plot beats and revelations follow familiar patterns in mystery and retellings. A few historical details have drawn minor nitpicks from sharp-eyed readers, though these don't derail the fun for most. As book one, it sets up a larger arc. Some threads (family secrets, Moriarty connections) hint at more to come, which leaves a few elements feeling introductory. If you enjoy atmospheric academia, gender-bending disguises, and intellectual cat-and-mouse games with a side of budding romance, pick this up. I'm looking forward to the sequel (A Lovely and Deadly Dance) to see where Irene and Sherlock's partnership (and personal tensions) head next.








.png)
