Showing posts with label Dark Fantasy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Dark Fantasy. Show all posts

Friday, September 25, 2026

#Review - Burn the Kingdom Down by Addie Thorley #YA #Fantasy

Series:
 Standalone
Format: 
448 pages, Hardcover
Release Date: April 7, 2026 
Publisher: Sourcebooks Fire
Source: Publisher
Genre: YA, Dark Fantasy

An action-packed enemies-to-lovers romantasy filled with a romance that will leave you breathless, betrayals that will rip your heart out, and a princess who will stop at nothing for revenge.

One year ago, Rowenna Harrack, the crown princess of Tashir, left her homeland in a wedding dress of chains—sent away to the enemy nation of Vanzador as a captive bride.

Now, Rowenna is dead. Brought home in a coffin after an alleged fall from a cliff.

Second-born princess, Indira, knows her sister's death was no accident. Desperate for truth and vengeance, Indira agrees to wed the prince so she can infiltrate Vanzador, find Rowenna's murderer, and burn their kingdom to the ground.

Indira's plan is simple, she will make nice until she can find out how to avenge her sister and free her country from the rival nation's stranglehold. But when Indira arrives, nothing is as terrible as Rowenna described. As Indira grows closer to her new husband, Prince Alaric, and uncovers more about Vanzador, the source of its powers, and what happened during Rowenna's final days, she’s no longer sure what—and who—to believe. Because everyone, even her sister, has secrets. Deadly ones. As allegiances shift and betrayals surface, Indira realizes the only person she can trust is herself. It’s time to step out of her sister’s shadow. Time to serve her own brand of justice.



Burn the Kingdom Down from Addie Thorley (author of An Affair of Poisons and the Night Spinner books) sits in that crowded space of enemies-to-lovers political fantasy, but it is less “chosen one with a sword” and more “grief-soaked murder mystery with plants, propaganda, and memory magic.” One year ago, crown princess Rowenna of Tashir was sent to the enemy mountain kingdom of Vanzador as a captive bride under a brutal treaty. 

Tashir is an underground garden realm that grows bagrava, a sacred plant that keeps its soil fertile; Vanzador’s royal family can move earth itself and, in return for bagrava tribute and a Tashiri princess, raised a mountain wall against marauders. Rowenna comes home in a coffin after an alleged fall from a cliff. Second-born princess Indira, a master gardener who has always lived in her sister’s shadow, does not believe it was an accident. 

When Vanzador demands a replacement bride, she has no choice but to accept her fate so that she can infiltrate the Fortress, find who killed Rowenna, and tear the kingdom down from the inside. Nothing she finds matches the monster-state her sister described. Prince Alaric is not the easy villain she expected. Everyone, including Rowenna, has secrets. The contrast between the two kingdoms is the book’s best idea. Tashir is soil, roots, and living magic; Vanzador is stone, cold, and a society that harvests memories as fuel. 

“Memory tithes” are a genuinely interesting system: identity can be extracted, stored, distorted, or weaponized. That ties the mystery, the politics, and Indira’s grief together instead of sitting on top of the plot as decoration. Indira is not a stabby superheroine. She is loyal, angry, naive in places, and shaped by a sister she idolized too long. The book is as much about stepping out of that shadow as it is about revenge. Alaric works as a counterpart rather than a dark-romance checklist: tension comes from competing loyalties and withheld information more than constant banter. 

When the romance lands, it is because it is earned slowly while they investigate together. Thorley also treats the “avenge my sister / infiltrate the enemy court” template as a mystery first. The structure is closer to a closed-house investigation than a war campaign. That will delight readers tired of endless set-piece battles and frustrate readers who want constant action. If you need a high-spice, high-action romantasy, this is not that. 

The romance is slow-burn and secondary to grief and investigation for long stretches. Content includes violence, death, grief, some sexual content, attempted assault, and emotional abuse. The book keeps asking what memory is worth—and who we are when the stories we were raised on are lies. National myths, sisterly worship, and personal identity all get the same treatment: they can be cultivated or drained. 

Indira’s arc from “burn it all” toward something more complicated is the emotional spine. Whether that landing feels earned is the main split among readers. Read this if you want YA romantasy with a plant-and-memory magic system, a murder mystery at the center, and a heroine who is more gardener-and-griever than warrior. Skip or sample first if you bounce off slow court-investigation middles or inconsistent trust-fall plotting.

NOTE: This book is currently on sale for a limited time. I don't get any money for posting this, but if you think you will enjoy the story, $1.99 at Amazon, B&N and Kobo is a good deal. 






Tuesday, August 4, 2026

#Review - Deathless by Julie Kagawa #YA #Fantasy

Series:
 Fateless # 2
Format: 
400 pages, Hardcover
Release Date: July 7, 2026
Publisher: HarperCollins US
Source: Publisher
Genre: Young Adult, Dark Fantasy

How does one kill the unkillable?

Sparrow and her companions have been left with an impossible task: slay the immortal Deathless King, whose magic siphons the very life of the world to sustain himself.

The answer may lie deep in the past, when those who would become Deathless Kings stormed the sanctuary of the goddess of Fate, in an attempt to remove their threads from the Weave and become immortal. They broke off a piece of the goddess’s loom and hurled it to the earth, where it still lies at the center of a dangerous wasteland called the World Scar.

For any chance against the Deathless King, Sparrow and her companions must brave the World Scar and reach the loom, which would grant the power of a goddess. But the journey is fraught with danger, and the powerful Deathless King determined to find them.

And if the loom is reached—what will the power of a goddess do to a mere mortal? Sparrow has no choice but to find out.


Julie Kagawa's Deathless is the second installment in the author's Fateless series. Deathless picks up with former thief Sparrow confronting the consequences of her identity as the Fateless—someone who can unravel the fates and destinies of those she touches, yet has none of her own—while facing an immortal threat that is draining the world itself. 

Sparrow and her companions (Kysa, Halek and Raithe) face an impossible charge: stop the Deathless King, an immortal whose magic sustains him by siphoning life from the land. The path forward leads into the past and a perilous journey toward a fragment of the goddess of Fate’s loom, hidden in the deadly World Scar—a lava-covered wasteland where even the air is poisonous. 

Reaching it could grant goddess-level power, but the risks to a mortal (and the pursuit by the Deathless King) are immense. Sparrow travels with Scarab Clan warrior Kysa, the carefree Fatechaser Halek (on their giant flying rock beetles), and the assassin Raithe, whose budding romance with Sparrow grows more complicated, including a visit to his mystic homeland. 

The group crosses dangerous territories, meets allies and foes, and navigates twists that keep the stakes high. The narrative balances the larger quest (confronting immortality and cosmic-scale threats tied to the Weave of fate) with personal costs, nightmares stemming from prior events, and interpersonal dynamics. Twists are deftly placed to maintain momentum through the Dead Lands and beyond. 

Notably, the book incorporates necessary background from Fateless smoothly enough that new readers can follow, while rewarding series fans with deeper exploration of the lore around the Deathless Kings, the goddess Maederyss, and the Tapestry/Weave. As a middle book in a trilogy, it escalates the conflict effectively and ends on a cliffhanger designed to heighten anticipation for the finale. 

Sparrow remains a compelling lead: a resourceful former thief grappling with power, responsibility, identity, and the absence of a predetermined path. Her emotional arc receives solid development alongside the action. The supporting cast shines—Kysa’s warrior perspective and cultural ties, Halek’s lighter, windswept Fatechaser philosophy providing contrast and humor, and Raithe’s enigmatic assassin background adding tension and depth. 

Building on the desert city of Kovass, the Dust Sea, ancient Deathless Kings, the Thieves Guild/Circle, and the theological framework of Maederyss weaving the Tapestry of the World, Deathless expands into new regions like the World Scar, the Dead Lands, and Irrikah. Unique elements—giant flying rock beetles as mounts, poisonous wastelands, blood magic/undead forces tied to the immortal king, and cultural details of groups like the Scarab Clan—create an immersive, distinctive setting that blends high fantasy with post-imperial decay and mythic stakes. 





Wednesday, July 29, 2026

#Review - A Curse of Beasts and Magic by Jeaniene Frost #Fantasy

Series:
 
Beautiful and Beastly (#1)
Format: 368 pages, Hardcover
Release Date: May 26, 2026
Publisher: Bramble
Source: Publisher
Genre: Dark Fantasy

New York Times bestselling author of The Night Huntress series Jeaniene Frost returns with a brand-new series! It’s Beauty and the Beast meets The Witcher, except Beauty IS the Beast, and he’s the Warden keeping mythical beings in check in our world and beyond.

Raine Stone is living a nightmare. Ever since she survived the attack that killed her family, she's been hiding a terrible secret--and a Beast inside her.

It feeds on violence and chaos, but she restrains its urges by playing vigilante on the city streets. Until one night, Raine uses the Beast’s energy to heal an elderly gentleman from a seemingly random attack and discovers a new world of danger—literally.

Remington “Remy” Byrne knows the wall between a realm of deadly mythic creatures and our own world is very fragile. After all, he’s the Warden who guards the gateways between them. Raine’s Beast contains power that could tip the scales in a sinister plot against Remy’s rule—if she allies with him.

Will they be friends or foes…or will their dangerous attraction turn into something else? And can our world be saved by their explosive alliance?



A Curse of Beasts and Magic is the first installment in author Jeaniene Frost's Beautiful and Beastly series. The series is a dark contemporary romantasy/urban fantasy that flips the Beauty and the Beast premise so the heroine is the one carrying the Beast. The series marks the author's return, and it blends portal fantasy elements, action, political intrigue among mythical beings, and medium-heat romance.
 
Lorraine “Raine” Stone (26), an ER nurse, has lived with a secret for 11 years: after surviving the attack that killed her mother and grandmother, she carries “Beithíoch” inside her. It feeds on violence, chaos, and pain. She keeps it in check by drawing on the energy of her hospital shifts and by acting as a nighttime vigilante against street criminals, sometimes using the Beast’s power to heal others. One night she intervenes to save an elderly man from abduction, using that power in a way that draws the attention of his grandson, Remington “Remy” Byrne (243, not a typo). 

Remy is far more than the polished CEO he appears to be. He is a Warden—a powerful magic-wielder responsible for guarding gateways between the human world and parallel realms filled with dangerous mythic creatures (including dragon shifters and the Tuatha Dé Danann), enforcing truces, and overseeing supernatural beings in his territory. Raine’s Beast makes her both a threat and a potential asset amid a plot against Remy’s position. What begins as wary antagonism and a strategic alliance (including a fake engagement/relationship for protection and access) develops into genuine attraction and mutual reliance, set against escalating dangers that pull them between the everyday world and other realms. 

Raine is a determined, morally grounded survivor who has structured her entire life around containing something monstrous inside her. Her dual roles as caregiver (healer) and vigilante give her an appealing complexity; she is tough and resourceful yet isolated and sometimes naïve about the larger magical world she is suddenly thrust into. Reviewers often praise her heart and agency, even when noting occasional moments of impulsiveness or limited knowledge that feel realistic for her circumstances. 

Remy is a classic powerful, morally gray, somewhat overbearing Warden/CEO type—authoritative, secretive for strategic reasons, protective, and carrying his own burdens and walls. Chemistry builds through banter, forced proximity, shared danger, and gradual trust. Their dynamic leans enemies-to-lovers and fake-dating with strong “touch her and die” energy; many readers found the push-pull and eventual emotional payoff satisfying, though some wanted more open communication or a slower emotional burn. Supporting characters (including family elements that hint at found-family potential) add flavor, even if not all are deeply developed yet. 

Tropes include fake dating/engagement, enemies-to-lovers, forced proximity, morally gray hero, and monstrous secrets. Attraction is intense, and the physical chemistry is emphasized. Spice is moderate. Frost constructs a layered setting: the ordinary modern world intersects with fragile gateways to other realms, Wardens as magical law enforcement, aura-based perception of violence/power, and a mix of familiar (shifters, fae-adjacent beings) and distinctive elements (specific creature abilities, transportation methods, political machinations). 

Pacing is generally fast, driven by action, chases, and escalating threats, balanced by quieter character and relationship moments. Overall, I enjoyed the set-up and beginning of this story, and wish that had continued for a few more chapters without the rush to jump each other's bones. It felt like Raine was engulfed by too many plot points, additional characters, and magical politics to really shine. She does get a few moments at the end to kick some ass.



CHAPTER ONE

I had to let the Beast feed tonight. I didn’t want to, but if I didn’t, what came next would be a lot worse.

I hurried along the rain-slicked Baltimore streets. The Inner Harbor area was still packed with people even though it was midnight. I wasn’t here for one of its many bars or late-night eateries, though. It just happened to be between my apartment and the hospital where I worked.

I kept walking. It only took a few blocks past the Inner Harbor’s more touristy area for the neighborhood to noticeably change. Abandoned buildings and iron-gated windows now dotted the rows of townhouses and mostly closed businesses. Foot traffic was also down unless you passed a bar. I was passing one now, and two twenty-something guys spilled out of it. With a sloppy smile, the brunet staggered after me.

“Hey, hot stuff, come here,” he slurred.

“No thanks,” I said firmly, and tucked some of my long, too-curly brown hair back into its ponytail.

“Come on!” he tried again.

Did he really think catcalling would work, especially on someone wearing medical scrubs? He was lucky I didn’t take him up on his offer. Even now, my vision changed, showing red swirls haloing the catcaller’s gloomy gray aura.

I tried to sidestep him, but he reached out and yanked me against him.

“Not so fast!” His hands ran down my sides, and—

Darkness stabbed out from my fingernails, turning them into sharp claws. I sank them into the catcaller. The Beast inside me clamped onto that supernatural tether, burning through the violence in the man’s psyche.

He screamed, and the red flares in his aura dimmed.

I snatched my hand away, shoving him and that inner Beast back. Otherwise, the Beast would consume the catcaller’s life force once it was done feasting on his violence.

The catcaller nearly fell. His friend caught him before he hit the pavement. My claws vanished with the same speed as the burn marks in my would-be groper’s skin.

“What the hell, Jackson?” his friend hissed, pulling the catcaller away. “Sorry, he’s drunk,” he said to me.

Jackson sagged in his friend’s grip. He was barely conscious from the Beast devouring his violent energy. The red flares were now gone from Jackson’s aura, too, leaving him haloed by what looked like an ashen cloak.

“What happened?” Jackson managed to mumble.

You became a snack, I thought grimly, increasing my pace as I walked away. But unfortunately, I still need a meal.

I never intended to be a nurse by day and a violence-eating vigilante by night, but here I was, twenty-six and doing both. Okay, a little more than both. I’d also given secret, supernatural assistance to a patient during my nursing shift tonight, even though doing so had consequences.

Desperate animals will gnaw off their own paw if left long enough in a trap. Well, I was the Beast’s trap, and using its power to heal made it desperate enough to gnaw through me unless I fed it what it craved most—violence.

I reached the next intersection, looking ahead to see if the Walk or Stop light was on. A bright light suddenly seared my vision. For a second, I thought it might be a passing car’s headlights, and then I realized it belonged to a person.

That person moved out from behind a cluster of people waiting for the light to change. I expected to see a small, wide-eyed face. Auras that radiant usually came from children. Instead, I saw the wrinkled visage of an elderly man. He had pale skin, gray hair, and he was dressed like he’d been cosplaying as a nineteenth-century librarian.

Two men suddenly ran up behind the elderly man. Their auras were bloodred and unusually tall, looming and swaying over them. One pressed his hand against the man’s mouth and dragged him off in the opposite direction.

The light changed. People crossed the street, oblivious to what had happened behind them. It was so fast, I would have missed it, too, if I hadn’t been staring right at the elderly man.

I went after them. I normally didn’t take on two guys at once, but the old guy was in trouble. That made these kidnappers my next meal. When the Beast was done with them, they’d be alive, but like the catcaller, they’d be a lot less dangerous.

His kidnappers moved unusually fast. I ran, but I still couldn’t keep up. Thankfully, the man’s aura left a trail of light that I followed. It led into an alley behind a pawnshop.

I normally avoided this part of town, but I kept going. The Beast’s hunger grew with every step. It wanted to kill them. I wouldn’t let it. I couldn’t rid myself of the Beast, but I could damn sure keep it on a diet.

I caught up with the two captors in time to see them haul the man over a fence. Now they were in the back of a scrap metal depository. Moments later, I heard a cry: “Stop! That hurts!”

The Beast surged, sensing the violence. I didn’t free it—I never willingly did—but I didn’t force it all the way back.

The Beast’s power scalded me. My skin felt too tight and my pulse raced. I took my coat off, threw it over the fence, and cleared the six-foot height in one leap.

The kidnappers spun around. The hoods of their sweatshirts were now down, revealing that one was blond and the other had brown hair. The old man was on the ground, blood streaming down his forehead. The brown-haired kidnapper gripped a metal pipe, its edge dripping with crimson.

“Drop it,” I said.

They laughed.

I didn’t blame them. I was only five-four, with an average build, and I had no weapons. Well, none that they could see.

The Beast let out a growl through my throat that caused the two men to pale. Yeah, no normal person could make that sound.

“The hell?” the blond one whispered.

I sprang toward the pipe-wielding guy. My front kick smashed into his chest. He went down, the pipe clattering from his hand. Not laughing now, was he? With my mixed martial arts training plus the Beast’s added power, I’d kicked him harder than someone five times my size.

The blond guy lunged at me.

The Beast’s claws shot out. I was about to drive them into him when something knocked me over from behind. My forehead slammed onto the concrete. Pain filled me, my vision swam, and I tasted blood.

What the hell?

The dark-haired guy was still on the ground, and the blond was right in front of me. Who had hit me from behind?

I scrambled to my feet and whirled around.

Nothing. Whoever it was must’ve backed into the yard where the night’s shadows thickened to a dark gloom. The stench of cayenne and ozone washed over me, so thick I almost gagged.

I whirled back. The blond was still there, but the other kidnapper was gone. A huge snake now rose up to stare at me. Holy shit, that thing was bigger than a telephone pole!

“Whatever you are, you’re dead,” it hissed at me.

It could talk?

My shock was costly. The snake’s strike slammed into me like a giant hammer. I fell back. Coils wrapped around me. I tried to fight it off, but it squeezed me like a massive fist.

Air burst out of my lungs. I tried to suck more in and couldn’t. Panic strafed me. I’d known there had to be other supernatural creatures aside from the one inside me. Now I’d finally found one, and it was trying to kill me.

The stench of agave drowned me as those coils squeezed harder. My bones groaned. Pain slashed through me. I tried to scream, but nothing came out. I was being crushed to death.

My skin burned and a vicious inner slash felt like acid. I knew that pain. The Beast was here.

Everything went black, and—

—I spat out a mouth full of ashes. The wind tried to blow more back in. I clamped my lips shut.

I was in the middle of the metal yard, naked and bloody. Nothing was left of the huge snake or the other kidnappers except piles of cold ashes swirling in the night breeze.

Dammit, I hadn’t wanted to kill them. The thing inside me was a murderer, but I wasn’t. Not by choice. Now I’d killed again, and it had been someone with a supernatural secret like me. All the answers I could’ve finally gotten, gone. The frustration cut like a knife.

At least I kept them from murdering that poor man. Unless the Beast had killed him, too? I couldn’t see his bright aura anymore. The Beast was full and satiated, and it had sunk too deep within me.

“Sir?” I called out.

No answer.

My heart lurched. The Beast normally only ate the violent, making their red auras an Open for Dinner sign to my supernatural stowaway. Don’t ask me why it preferred them. No one gave me a Beast’s Guide to Binge Eating when I became infected with the thing eleven years ago. At first, I thought I might be a werewolf, but sadly not. If werewolves were real, those lucky fuckers only had to deal with their inner monsters one weekend a month. I had to deal with mine every single day.

But if the Beast was hungry enough, it would eat anyone, violent or no.

“Where are you, sir?” I called out again, snatching my coat off the fence where I’d left it.

“Here,” a pained voice groaned.

I put my coat on and ran toward his voice.

I found the man slumped by a large heap of scrap metal piled up for sorting. Blood streamed from his head, and clear liquid that might have been spinal fluid leaked from his nose. If I didn’t do something, he’d die.

I put my hands on his head while pulling on the Beast’s power. Three minutes later, I was bent over, vomiting from channeling too much magic, too fast.

Gentle hands smoothed back my hair. “There now, lass,” the man said in a lilting Irish accent. “You’re all right.”

My gag turned into a choked laugh. I sat back, wiping at my mouth. “More importantly, how are you?”

He gave me the sweetest smile. “Alive, thanks t’you. Thought you meant to kill me when you turned into a beithíoch.”

Did he just call me a “behemoth”? Eh, that was a kind descriptor compared to whatever the Beast was. More importantly, I’d healed him, but now I had to leave town. Again. At best, whichever police officer took the man’s report would think that he was overwrought from the attempted kidnapping, but I couldn’t take that risk. Not after nearly getting arrested in Georgia last year.

I bit back my disappointment. I was just starting to get comfortable here. I had a decent job, a place to live where the neighbors didn’t question my late-night comings and goings, and even a pet now. Still, safety beat out comfort.

“Do you have someone to call to pick you up?” I asked him.

He gave me a look of such heartbreaking confusion, I patted his arm. As a nurse, I’d seen that look on countless dementia patients before. He didn’t remember who to call.

“Do you know your name?” I asked in a softer voice.

His whole body trembled as he said, “No.”

“It’s fine,” I said, patting him again. “I can still help you. Do you mind if I look in your pockets?”

He didn’t mind, but to my dismay, he lacked a phone, wallet, or any identification. He only had a single, laminated business card with FRONTVIEW REPUBLIC printed on the front and a handwritten phone number on the back.

My brows went up. Frontview Republic was one of the largest commercial real estate and investment corporations in the Northeast. Their name had been splashed across headlines recently due to a big project in Maryland and Pennsylvania.

“Stay here,” I said, and searched for the rest of my stuff.

I found my clothes and purse near the bloodstains and ash piles. The huge snake and the other kidnappers must have put up a hell of a fight. The Beast normally killed too quickly to draw anyone’s blood.

I couldn’t believe I’d finally come across another supernatural creature, only to still end up knowing nothing.

Rain started pouring in sheets. I used the deluge to wash the blood off my face and hands. Then I shoved the remains of my ripped-up medical scrubs into my coat’s deep pockets. The rain should wash away all the kidnappers’ blood as well as their ashes, leaving no trace of their deaths behind.

I returned to the man and led him to an awning that blocked most of the rain. Thankfully, my burner phone was working, which meant the Beast had been free at least ten minutes. Nothing electronic worked around the Beast when it first took over. I dialed the number on the business card and put it on speaker while I checked the man for more injuries.

“Who is this?” a smooth baritone voice answered.

“Is this Frontview Republic?” I asked.

“Who is this?” the voice repeated with such command that I almost said “Raine Stone” before I caught myself.

The man’s condition was tragic, but it had also saved me. He could tell everyone that he’d seen a woman transform into a huge creature that had killed two men plus a huge snake, and no one would believe him. Maybe I didn’t have to move again after all.

“Do you know a sixty-something man with an Irish accent who dresses like he raided a Sherlock Holmes movie set?” I asked.

“Yes.” His tone changed to palpable menace. “Where is he?”

“Safe,” I replied shortly. “But he very nearly wasn’t. Some men kidnapped him and almost killed him tonight.”

“Oh?” The man’s tone now became so velvety, I swore I almost felt it brush over me. “If you assisted in his rescue, then you will be well rewarded. Once again, where is he?”

“You must be rich,” I said with all the annoyance I wasn’t allowed to articulate when I was at work. “Only the wealthy think people help others for a reward instead of the simple reason that someone needed help.”

Anger replaced that luxurious tenor. “If you don’t tell me where Brendan is right now—”

“Brendan!” A delighted expression lit the man’s face. “My name is Brendan! And that’s Remy. He takes care of me. Don’t worry, Remy. The beithíoch is helping me.”

Okay, that word wasn’t “behemoth.” It had too many vowels, but new words were the least of my concerns. Headlights shone along the road that ran between the recycling plant and the train tracks; a reminder that someone could stumble upon us.

“He’ll be at the Helping Hands Shelter in twenty minutes,” I said, and hung up. Then I smiled and held out my hand. “Brendan? Would you escort me down the street? It’s not safe for a lady to walk alone.”

His smile deepened his wrinkles. He’d seen the Beast inside me, so he knew I didn’t need “escorting.” Still, he held out his arm while his periwinkle-blue eyes brightened.

“I’d be delighted.”



CHAPTER TWO



I watched from across the street as Brendan walked the final block to the shelter alone. I’d been right to be cautious. Before Brendan reached the front door, a black Mercedes sped down the street and screeched to a stop beside him.

“Remy!” I heard Brendan say before a tall figure leapt out. I caught a glimpse of black hair, broad shoulders, and a shadowed jaw before the man hustled Brendan into the back seat.

The car sped away at once.





Monday, June 8, 2026

#Review - The Library of Lost Girls by Kristen Pipps #YA #Fantasy

Series: Standalone
Format:
336 pages, Hardcover
Release Date: October 28, 2025
Publisher: Delacorte Press
Source: Publisher
Genre: Young Adult, Dark Fantasy

When her sister returns from finishing school a total stranger, a teen seeks out the cause and discovers that the cost of becoming a perfect lady is much higher—and more sinister—than ever expected. A lush, gothic tale that will haunt readers long after they turn the last page.

Gwen Donovan adores her beautiful and rebellious older sister, Izzy. But the Izzy who returns from the Delphi School for Girls is not the sister who left. Now she is Isolde: dull and complacent and—most shocking—eager to marry.

Gwen is determined to discover what happened to Izzy at Delphi, and the only solution she can conceive of is to cheat her way into the mysterious school. If she can see for herself what they did, maybe she can get her Izzy back.

But Delphi is far from the finishing school Gwen expects. Sinister shadows lurk in the hallways of the remote estate, and she is told to never leave her room after dark. More curious, though, are the thousands of books, each with the name of a girl on its spine. They line the walls from floor to ceiling, and the students are forbidden to read them.

Delphi says they’re reforming the girls, but when Gwen discovers a note left for her by her sister, she realizes that what is happening at the school is more terrifying than she could ever have imagined. There’s something dark at the center of Delphi, and somehow it’s tied to those books—and to the girls who are sent there. And if Gwen doesn’t confront what hides in the shadows, it won’t be just Izzy who’s lost forever.


The Library of Lost Girls is the debut novel from author Kristen Pipps. The Library of Lost Girls is an atmospheric YA gothic dark fantasy/horror which blends dark academia, sisterhood, supernatural elements, and sharp feminist commentary in a haunting 1893 setting. The story is set off the coast of Canada in a place called Delphia School for Girls. Gwen Donovan idolizes her older sister Izzy, a vibrant, rebellious spirit who defies societal expectations. When Izzy returns from four years at the remote Delphi School for Girls, she has transformed into "Isolde"—docile, compliant, and disturbingly eager to marry a near-stranger. 

Horrified by the change, Gwen schemes her way into Delphi to uncover the truth and reclaim her sister. What she finds is no ordinary finishing school. Perched on an icy, isolated island, Delphi features sinister moving shadows, strict rules against leaving rooms after dark, and walls lined floor-to-ceiling with thousands of forbidden books—each bearing a girl's name on its spine. Students undergo "reformation" in the mysterious Writing Room, emerging altered or amnesiac. As Gwen befriends other girls and deciphers clues (including a note from Izzy), she confronts a darkness tied to these books, the girls' lost identities, and patriarchal forces far more sinister than etiquette lessons. 

The story builds from creeping unease to full-blown horror, with themes of agency, identity erasure, found family, and resistance. Pipps excels at gothic immersion. The remote estate, shadowy hallways, locked rooms, and eerie library create a claustrophobic, foreboding vibe that lingers. The 1893 historical backdrop—finishing-school lessons in hosting, budgeting for husbands, and propriety—amplifies the horror of "reforming" girls into perfect ladies. At its heart, this is a story that parallels real historical (and ongoing) pressures on women to conform, stripping away personality for societal "perfection." 

The dialogue and details feel modern rather than strictly period-accurate (think Bridgerton vibes over rigid historical realism), which can jar in a 1893 setting. Pacing occasionally slows in the middle with repetitive exploration, and the fantasy/horror elements ramp up gradually—more creeping dread than constant action. My last concern was for the ending, which felt open-ended and rushed. If you are into sapphic romances, this book is for you. 



Chapter One

New York City, 1893

I should mingle with my sister’s wedding guests. It’s what Mother sent me down here to do, and the foyer is bustling with New York’s finest. Long trains of silk and satin covered in delicate flowers trail along the rugs that Father had imported from overseas. White-­gloved hands grasp fans that hide the snicker of laughter and the rolling of eyes. Wisps of smoke from cigars passed in the smoking room sneak tendrils out into the common space. I should find my fan, fashioned purposely to match my new blue gown. But I can only stand amidst it all, grim-­faced and wishing for a ghost who lives only in my memories.

A ghost who somehow grew into a bride. The subject of the framed photo that sits atop a mahogany table covered with fine lace and delicate rose petals. There’s another photo beside hers in a matching gold filigree frame, but I don’t care as much to look at Astor Wallingford, my soon-­to-­be brother-­in-­law. Instead, I’m fixated the photo of Izzy—­or Isolde, as she is known now.

It’s impossible to tell Izzy’s exact shade of blond hair in the black-­and-­white photo, or the fact that the dress she’s wearing is a flattering shade of pink that would make me look like an overripe tomato. But the slight upturn of her lips as she coyly looks over her shoulder shines through. Her eyes hint at a demureness befitting a young lady newly out to society.

They’re nothing like the wildfire eyes that used to dance around, alight as she regaled me with tales of her own making or goaded me into imaginative adventures around the house.

“Your sister is quite beautiful.”

I turn around to find myself face to face with the one person I was hoping to avoid. Lydia Heathersworth.

And, as to be expected, her gaggle of empty-­headed cronies stand behind her, whispering thinly veiled snide remarks into their fans.

“It’s lovely to see you, Lydia,” I say, playing the role of hostess.

She quirks her perfectly shaped mouth into a half smile. We both know I’m lying. Despite our parents’ greatest attempts, Lydia and I have never been friends. I was always too odd for her, spoke at the wrong times, didn’t know the right things to say. When we were five, before I realized what it really meant, I called her pretty, said I would like to marry her someday. Our parents wrote it off as a silly thing a child might say, but Lydia never let me forget it. Never let me forget the fact that she knew that secret truth of mine. So I became the butt of the joke my mother had always hoped I’d be on the other side of.

And her cousin is marrying my sister today.

“That finishing school of Isolde’s truly worked wonders,” Lydia says. “Who knew such a terrible child could grow into a pillar of society? Gorgeous too.” She gestures to the photograph we stand in front of. “She was away for a long time, never even came back to visit, did she?”

“Izzy loved it there,” I explain, a lie I was coached to tell as soon as she left. “She adored England and wanted to stay close to my cousins.” But our only cousins live in New York. Mother never explained the reason behind the lie, and after a while I learned not to ask questions. Izzy was at the Delphi School for Girls and would return at graduation.

I don’t even know if the school was in England.

“Is that so?” Lydia—­perfect society girl Lydia—­asks with the arch of an eyebrow. Her eyes track deliberately down my face, her insinuation impossible to miss.

It’s common knowledge to anyone who knew me as a child that I didn’t have a scar, then suddenly I did. And it appeared right when my sister left for school.

No one has ever outright asked, but I know they’ve wondered. The older, prettier—­albeit more rambunctious—­Donovan girl was sent away just as the younger, more awkward one debuted a scar that ran bright pink from eyebrow to chin. The look of it doesn’t matter to me as much as the looks it brings me. That and the constant reminder of why my sister was sent away.

I can’t let her leave again, especially not while she’s still a shell of her former self. Lydia may see Isolde as a woman to aspire to, but all I’ve ever wanted was to be like the Izzy who was taken away from us when she was fourteen.

“Excuse me,” I say, and quickly push away from Lydia and the other girls.

The girls snicker and I hear one of them say, “What an odd duck.”

Another says, “A complete oddity.”

I weave around full-­bodied skirts, canes, and tables prepped for serving after the ceremony. I’m swept away by an older woman wearing an old-­fashioned hoop skirt that is both long and wide enough that I have to exit the parlor on the far side of the room near the entryway instead of through the servants’ exit, which would have made my escape faster. Hardwood turns soft beneath my feet; I catch a heel on the edge of the burgundy runner that Father brought back from his last trip to India and slam into a hard wall.

“Oof,” I grunt, looking up. The wall is actually a man, a full foot taller than me, dressed in perfectly tailored tails and a velvet top hat adorned uniquely with a single peacock feather.

“My apologies,” I mutter.

“Not at all, Miss Donovan,” the man says with a voice like syrup. His lips curl into a smile that feels like a secret. He knows who I am. And while he looks vaguely familiar, I cannot place him. Perhaps a friend of the groom? He appears to be young—­likely right about Astor’s age. His face is more round than angular, his blond sideburns a bit patchy, as if he might struggle to grow a full beard. A friend from school, perhaps? I shake it off and scurry away. I know I should engage with him, force myself into a conversation after my horrifically rude display, but I need to leave this room. To find Izzy.

I manage to make it back to the foyer without falling into another guest just as Mother floats down the central staircase in a gown dripping in pearls like a queen, a tiara balanced atop her carefully crafted chignon. Her smile is placid, practiced. So like Izzy’s these days. She lands gently on the silk carpet and presses a delicate gloved hand on Mr. Wallingford’s elbow before approaching me. I’m not sure I’ve ever seen my mother’s bare hands.

“Gwendolyn,” she says, speaking out of the corner of her mouth, all the while keeping her smile perfectly in place. To Mr. Wallingford, I’m sure her smile is the picture of the ideal hostess. I don’t miss the dart of her eyes, though, so pointedly directing me to turn myself around and be pleasant, entertain her guests. But I don’t have it in me to settle for complacency, so I push past her and ignore the forced laugh she expels.

I hurry to the stairs, lifting the front of my skirt just enough so I won’t fall face-­first. I’m tempted to take the steps two at a time, to get away from the commotion as quickly as possible, but I can still feel Mother’s eyes on me, so I walk at an acceptable pace.

My shoulders slump the moment I’m out of view, no longer on display. No longer expected to perform. The brass handle on Izzy’s bedroom door at the end of the hall gleams bright and new. We moved into the Dakota less than three months after Izzy left, and the room designated to be hers was rarely entered.

She’s only just come back, and now she’s going to leave me again. I know that Mother and Father are thrilled by the transformation that their previously near-­devilish child has made, but she isn’t herself. Marrying Astor, especially since she barely even knows him, is a choice Izzy never would have made before. I can’t imagine what will happen with her next. This is my last chance to get her to stay, to see reason. She’s the only person who has ever truly listened to me; that girl must be inside her still somewhere. I just need to find the right words, though I never do seem to find them when it matters most. I grip the handle as if the door is ready to swallow me whole, the brass cold beneath the pads of my fingers.

“Gwen, is that you?” Izzy’s voice is muffled by the thick brown oak between us. I haven’t yet turned the doorknob—­my shadow must be visible through the crack at my feet. “Gwenie?” My ribs contract at the sound of the name my sister used to call me. She hasn’t used it since her return.

I twist and press forward.

Light streams in from the window that overlooks Central Park, draping my sister in a heavenly glow as she sits poised on her silk chaise. Even as she sits, I can see that Izzy’s waist has been pulled tight, in the style of Princess Maud. She must be uncomfortable beneath the folds of her crinoline skirt as she extends her delicate fingers toward me, finespun and exquisite lace tracing up her arms. I help her stand and press down a wrinkle at the base of her bustle, adjust the lace at her chest. Minor adjustments nobody would notice against her overall beauty.

“Your dress looks lovely on you. You look quite stunning,” she says, reminding me of what should have been my line. But the gentle smile that crosses her lips implies she’s being genuine.